You ever randomly decide at 3 am that you are gonna turn your life around so you decide to spend hours scrolling Pinterest and YouTube, looking for the fastest workouts to give you the best body possible? But you start to notice this weird trend where every workout towards women focuses on one specific part of the body. Becoming a blur of “Get toned arms in 15 minutes” or “Build the butt of your dreams in 1 Week!” or “Perfectly Sculpted Abs in 30 days.” Instead of focusing on health, it seems like these fitness influencers and apps promote that our body is a collection of broken parts, needing to be fixed. This message is everywhere you look, constantly pointing out the flaws women need to fix.
I only remembered this trend when reading Young’s essay about throwing like a girl. But more specifically, she talks about a phenomenon called “discontinuous unity” that perfectly captures this feeling. Basically, it’s the idea that women are often taught to move their bodies in a disconnected way, not as one fluid, whole unit. Her example is throwing a ball. She points out that a girl often throws using just her arm, while the rest of her body stays pretty still. A boy, on the other hand, usually puts his whole body into it by twisting his torso, moving his feet, and using what Young calls his “total motorium” to get the job done. This creates a weird feeling where the part of your body doing the work feels totally separate from the parts that are just… hanging out. It’s like your arm is on a mission, but the rest of you isn’t even on the team.
Similar to this example, workout plans made for women that promote “abs challenges” or “leg day” basically train women to perform this mode of discontinuous unity. We are told we need to isolate parts of our body that just need a quick fix in order to get our perfect body. Young argues that this discontinuity comes from women being conditioned to experience their body as an object to be looked at, rather than a subject of action. These workouts focus on aesthetic goals of molding your butt, legs, arms, etc. to fit a certain beauty standard instead of improving the actual health and function of your body. It is just another way to push the idea that women must shape and decorate their bodies to visually please men. In contrast to workouts like dance or yoga, where the goal is to get your whole body moving in sync.
Looking back, this connection seems obvious, but it’s not something I could have noticed when I was 12 years old and hated the way I look. I gobbled up any of these workouts I could find, hoping that one could give me the perfect body that it promoted. Even though I stopped participating in them myself, there are still many young girls doing the exact same thing. It makes me wonder if the cycle will always repeat itself with new, unaware girls who may never read Young’s essay in eight years to connect the dots.
I can’t even count how many times I’ve been on Pinterest and scrolled past one of these challenges. Honestly, I think when I was young, I had a board full of them and even attempted them a couple of times. No one ever pointed out that, hey, maybe if you want to feel better in your body, you need to do more than one thing at a time. That 30 day planking challenge wasn’t going to “fix” my body image, but I was so sure that it would if I could just complete it. Even now, I struggle to not segment myself when I work out. I have found that I do better doing full body workouts as opposed to having arm day, leg day, core day, and so on and so forth. I think the body is a complex thing, and while these workouts may work for some people, they definitely don’t work for everyone, despite the sort of generalizations they cause people to make about themselves.
I think the most fascinating part about these fitness trends is the way in which they re-invent themselves every once in a while. For example, today many fitness TikTokers have young girls convinced they need to eat 1.5 times their body weight in protein in order to have a thin waist but large, plump glutes. While it is important to emphasize the need for protein, they lack the expertise to tell people what and how they should be eating. Everyone’s body is different and needs different things. It’s just this reinvention of diet culture and telling women and young people what to do with their bodies and how to do it. It’s wrapped in chicken breast and cottage cheese this time.
I think this concept of discontinuity unity can also connect to the stigma with women when it comes to weightlifting. Some women will often feel judged to get to their full potential because of their perception. Some men will also bash buff women because they look too “masculine”. When some women hear this. they start saying phrases like “I don’t want to get that big” when they’re asked to lift a 15lb weight by their trainer. Society’s idea of a woman raises women to be fragile and indulge in health benefits even if their paying for the help.